Atheists Can Go To Heaven? Did Pope Francis Say Something New?

Some folks in the mainstream media are worked up because Pope Francis actually said that an atheist might go to heaven.  His remarks, from an article in the Italian newspaper La Repubblica, are being hyped as an example of Francis’s striking out on a new path, one different from that of his papal predecessors.  Here is a story from the UK Telegraph, linked from the Drudge Report.  This is the relevant portion quoted in the story:

The Pope wrote: “The question for those who do not believe in God is to follow their own conscience. Sin, even for a non-believer, is when one goes against one’s conscience.  To listen and to follow your conscience means that you understand the difference between good and evil.”  He said that the “mercy of God has no limits” and encompassed even non-believers.

Did the pope really say something new here?  Is he really opening up the Church in a way that departs from its past teaching?  Not really.  Here is one of the opening paragraphs from John Paul II’s encyclical, Veritatis Splendor:

Pope Francis speaks to reporters aboard his plane while returning to Rome from World Youth Day. (AP Photo/Luca Zennaro, Pool)

Pope Francis speaks to reporters aboard his plane while returning to Rome from World Youth Day. (AP Photo/Luca Zennaro, Pool)

The Church knows that the issue of morality is one which deeply touches every person; it involves all people, even those who do not know Christ and his Gospel or God himself. She knows that it is precisely on the path of the moral life that the way of salvation is open to all.The Second Vatican Council clearly recalled this when it stated that “those who without any fault do not know anything about Christ or his Church, yet who search for God with a sincere heart and under the influence of grace, try to put into effect the will of God as known to them through the dictate of conscience… can obtain eternal salvation”. The Council added: “Nor does divine Providence deny the helps that are necessary for salvation to those who, through no fault of their own, have not yet attained to the express recognition of God, yet who strive, not without divine grace, to lead an upright life. For whatever goodness and truth is found in them is considered by the Church as a preparation for the Gospel and bestowed by him who enlightens everyone that they may in the end have life”

The Telegraph also detects a change in the incoming Vatican Secretary of State’s remark that celibacy for the clergy is not a matter of Catholic doctrine:

In a further sign that the Church is edging towards more openness, Archbishop Pietro Parolin, a Vatican diplomat who will next month become the Pope’s deputy as secretary of state, said that the principle of celibacy among clergy was “ecclesiastical tradition” rather than “Church dogma” and therefore open to discussion.

The Church is changing, “edging towards openness,” because a Vatican official stated what every informed Catholic already knows and has known since long before Francis became pope?

Lesson: journalists are not competent to say what is new in the Church if they have never in the first place bothered to learn what the Church has traditionally taught.


Categories:Church News Pope Francis Theology

21 thoughts on “Atheists Can Go To Heaven? Did Pope Francis Say Something New?

  1. Liz Innes says:

    Isaiah 64:6 and Romans 3:10 – none of us are righteous, all our righteous acts are but filthy rags – it is not our works but our love of Jesus and our willingness to take up our cross and follow him that leads to salvation.

  2. Bill says:


  3. Debbie says:

    The Bible
    New Testament
    John 14:6

  4. john says:

    leave it to god to decide who goes to hell or heaven.

  5. C. Thompson says:

    You need to go back a re-read the article. I do not find the Pope saying what you claim.

  6. Mary Ann says:

    I hear the Pope saying…Do good, be a good person, have a good heart, a good spirit within you…and we will meet one another there! God is BIGGER than our little thoughts…His love is Greater than our concept of Love…He is so far beyond our thoughts and the way we see things…scripture says so…This discussion is way beyond us because we don’t have the heart of God. This is evidenced here in the comments. A person can be a “Believer” and not act like one. Indeed some of us say we believe and do the opposite…like condemn others and speak of them as lesser than ourselves. We still don’t get it…It’s not about the other guy…It’s about OUR HEART towards others. What good is condemning anyone..we cannot see their hearts and souls. We have done so much damage to the work of Christ by our judging and condemning and rejecting of others, So leave it to God, the all loving and all Just Father.

    1. nicola says:

      Well said, Mary Ann.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>



Receive our updates via email.